Not only are the
three films included in The Benoît Jacquot Collection all from the 1990s, they
each have a connection in themes and characters, especially when considering
the commonalities in the young female roles. I can’t decide whether the
approach is feminist or merely a representation of how the beauty of youth is
coveted by an endless stream of middle-aged men in all three narratives. Either
way, the ideas from these movies only work because of the enigmatic and
captivating performances from Jacquot’s leading ladies, each balancing
somewhere between girlishly adolescent behavior and the maturity of womanhood.
The Disenchanted (1990) stars Judith
Godrèche as 17-year-old Beth, a reactionary teen whose stubbornness leads her
to make rash decisions. In the opening scene of the film, Beth’s boyfriend
suggests that she sleep with another man to be sure that she really loves him.
Though this is clearly an immature attempt at being reassured that she cares,
Beth’s immediate acceptance of the challenge shows her ability to match his
childish behavior. The fact that she refers to her boyfriend as
“what’s-his-name” and constantly surrounds herself with other adoring men is a
clear sign that Beth is not attached in any way.
This immature
behavior continues with the naivety with which Beth approaches nearly every
aspect of her life, though some has developed out of necessity. Her mother is
never seen out of bed, only capable of providing for her family with the help
of a wealthy man that they casually refer to as Sugar Daddy. Men do not come
off fantastic in this film because of their desire to possess or control the
beautiful women of the narrative, but the women are no less at fault when they
see men as nothing more than a financial asset which can be manipulated. Though
the message is somewhat feminist, it turns a mirror on the hypocrisy of women
who don’t want to be objectified but are willing to see men as little more than
cash machines.
A Single Girl (1995) continues the
tradition of narratives involving immature women facing constant
objectification by the men surrounding them, though 19-year-old Valerie
(Virginie Ledoyen) is far better equipped to handle the task. Taking place in
real time, the narrative unfolds over the morning of Valerie’s first day
working at a luxury hotel. Having just told him that she is pregnant, Valerie’s
volatile and impatient boyfriend (Benoît Magimel) waits to discuss their
situation in a nearby café. Meanwhile, Valerie is forced to endure the sexual
harassment from one of her male co-workers, not to mention the perversions
faced by irrational and irate hotel guests. It would be far easier to feel
sympathy for Valerie, but she remains coldly distant for much of the film. Even
when making the wise and mature decisions involving her situation, Valerie’s
age and immaturity often shine through. This is most obvious in a sequence
where Valerie is so frustrated by the lack of passion in her boyfriend’s
goodbye that she nearly walks into oncoming traffic, forcing the young man to
save her, adding Valerie to the list of female characters balancing between
youth and maturity.
Keep It Quiet (1999) is easily my least
favorite in this collection, mostly because it lacks the narrative simplicity
of the first two. There are too many characters, too many coincidences, and a
number of unresolved questions, but the themes from the first two films seem to
carry over into one of the minor characters. At the center of the story is an
upper class family that includes a television news personality (Vincent
Lindon), a former CEO (Fabrice Luchini) recently released from a prison
sentence for white collar crime, and his patient wife (Isabelle Huppert). The
narrative is clearly a satire, though much of the humor is likely to be lost in
translation despite the relevance of the message in today’s society.
The Disenchanted is contained on its own
Blu-ray disc, while A Single Girl and
Keep It Quiet are included together
on the second disc in the collection. Each of the films come with their own
special features, with an audio commentary by critics Wade Major and Tim
Cogshell, on-camera discussions between Jacquot and Kent Jones, and theatrical
re-release trailers for each of the films.
Entertainment Value:
6/10
Quality of
Filmmaking: 8/10
Historical
Significance: 7/10
No comments:
Post a Comment
Agree? Disagree? Questions for the class? All comments are welcome...