(The
following is an excerpt of Ryan Izay’s 2007 review via Real Movie News)
Independent
filmmaker and soon-to-be Hollywood’s
hot commodity after directing Pineapple Express, David Gordon Green is a name
that is usually connected to rural American stories, simple and somehow still
intensely engaging and fascinating. There is an undeniable link in D.G. Green’s
choice to produce Shotgun Stories, a film in a similar vein and pacing. In
fact, Shotgun Stories is the ultimate rural American story, about a blood feud.
Brothers fighting brothers brings the undeniable connection to our country’s
history, and basing his film on such a strong subject Jeff Nichols is able to
complete his directorial debut with a simple and extremely effective piece of
independent filmmaking. There less shots in the film, more attention is given
to those chosen, and they are all confident and impressive choices for a
first-time director. But most impressive is the cast. Michael Shannon is a long
under-rated actor and he carries the film in many scenes, but what is more
amazing is the way Nichols seems to bring the best out of actors who I usually
tend to dislike. Somehow none of the performances feel like a performance,
which adds realism to the story, which drags us in with beautiful and dangerous
images.
The
significant details that make this otherwise film straightforward film
something marvelous from each scene to the next are not always subtle, but they
are always simple. The names of the brothers that are feuding are a perfect
example. While the brothers from the legitimate Hayes family are named Cleaman
(Michael Abbott, Jr.), Mark (Travis Smith), Stephen (Lynnsee Provence), and John (David Rhodes), the
brothers from the illegitimate Hayes family are simple named Son (Shannon), Boy
(Douglas Ligon), and Kid (Barlow Jacobs). Even from birth it is obvious that
the illegitimate brothers were given less care and attention, and they
naturally are filled with feelings of resentment towards their half-brothers
who have received so many more opportunities while they were left with a
spiteful mother and absent father.
Thirty-some
years of repression leaves Son feeling unsatisfied after hearing their father
has died, and after crashing the funeral they were not invited to he makes a
rash speech about what a horrible father he was to them, regardless of how well
he treated his second family. This speech upsets Mark and Stephen Hayes the
most, and a gripping cycle of revenge becomes inevitable. Having never had
parents that actually cared, the illegitimate Hayes brothers have learned to
count on each other and their sense of protection over each other is strong
enough to create tense and unsettling situations. Son is a man who already
bears scars from a shotgun across his back. Although stories circulate that he
received these from a robbery gone wrong or from cheating on another man’s
wife, the only important truth is that he got the scars protecting his
brothers. As expert as the direction is, Nichols also manages a script that
never overdoes it on dialogue. Part of what makes the actors so believable is
their lack of emoting. They don’t talk about the past, their feelings, or much
else that isn’t of immediate significance. We hear more gossip and bullshit
than actual facts, leaving us to decide what to believe from the time we spend
with them.
Even as I
write this review I am amazed at how directly I speak of the characters in the
film. Few films have the power to make me forget that I am watching actors, and
David Gordon Green’s sophomore film, All the Real Girls floored me in a similar
way. Half-Nelson and nearly every performance Gosling gives seem to do the
same. These are the type of films that can be cherished, because the filmmakers
brought something to life in a way that returns my hope that film can always
retain a certain element of magic, even without making 3-D pictures or using
blockbuster special effects. Shotgun Stories is more than just another film, it
is a gift, a piece of art, and truly unforgettable.
Some films may
not be well suited for a music-only track, but this is the best candidate I
have seen in some time. The music is simple and perfectly suited for the tone
of the film, and the cinematography along with the simple music by the band
Lucero is perfect.
2. Pineapple Express (2008)
My top choice
in the Desert Island Stoner Comedies list is also number two on my D.G.G. list,
because it is more than just a film for potheads. Pineapple Express is Green’s
sellout film, being that it was the first time he directed material that he
hadn’t written himself and it was a his first blockbuster with stars and a
finale filled with action and effects. After this film he was lulled into
several other mainstream films, with screenplays written by others. The result
is a watering down of the director’s natural and iconic style, but Pineapple
Express is the perfect marriage of mainstream action/comedy and that signature
directorial approach.
Green’s films
prior to Pineapple Express always took place in southern small towns, often in North Carolina where the
director attended school. This small-town vibe carries over into Pineapple
Express, with plenty of insert shots of naturalistic background actors and country
scenery. The final shootout occurs in a barn, which is an odd location for a
film which has an otherwise urban-oriented screenplay. There is also the
wonderful addition of McBride to the cast, whose longtime friendship with the
director has greatly helped his career.
1. All the Real Girls (2003)
Though this
was neither Zooey Deschanel nor Paul Schneider’s first film, it was a big break
for both of them. It was their first starring roles, and under Green’s
direction they are at their best. If I were to make a Desert Island
list for both of these actor, All the Real Girls would be number one on those
lists as well. The acting is spectacular all around in Green’s second feature,
which is ironic considering he took a dramatically different approach in
casting the main roles in this film. George Washington was met with such
critical success that even supporting roles are easily filled by marvelous
actors, and Green shows his abilities as a director are even more spectacular
when working with trained talent. The film co-stars Shea Whigham (Silver Lining Playbook, Jeff Nichols’ Take Shelter), Danny McBride, and
Patricia Clarkson (Shutter
Island,
The East). There is also the odd
addition of Matt Chapman, best known as the voice actor for the web series “Homestar
Runner.” His character is named Strong Bad in both the series and this film.
There is no
easy way to explain why I love All the Real Girls so much. It is a film which
often infuriates me, sparking a great number of emotional reactions that are only
possible with great filmmaking. The characters are flawed but real, and by the
end of the film it is impossible not to have an investment in their lives. This
film breaks my heart, but only because of how much it is able to capture the
feeling of heartbreak. Even when the situations in the film are in no way
reminiscent of my own personal heartbreak, I find myself relating to the
characters and feeling their pain. First love and the subsequent heartbreak is
universal, and Green’s ability to direct his actors makes it possible for
audiences to experience a rural southern lifestyle unlike their own and still
relate to the emotions of the film’s characters with ease.